Most of what kids hear about the first Thanksgiving fits on a paper plate turkey. Some of it is wrong. The real story has eels, a three-day harvest party, a 66-day ocean crossing and a Wampanoag leader who arrived with about 90 men.
Every fact here was checked against Plimoth Patuxet Museums, Pilgrim Hall Museum, the National Archives, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the White House Historical Association and the Library of Congress. It is written for kids ages 5 to 11 and the grown-ups reading along.
You get 56 facts in seven groups, plus a myth or fact game to play at the table. Start where the story starts: a harvest in the fall of 1621.
Jump to a Section:
- 1621: The Harvest Celebration Everyone Calls the First Thanksgiving
- The Wampanoag Side of the Story
- What Was Really on the Menu in 1621
- How Thanksgiving Became an Official Holiday
- Turkey Facts That Will Ruffle Your Feathers
- Parades, Pardons and Football
- 5 Thanksgiving Myths Kids Hear All the Time
- Which Thanksgiving Facts to Start With
1621: The Harvest Celebration Everyone Calls the First Thanksgiving
The first Thanksgiving was a harvest celebration that lasted about three days in the fall of 1621 at Plymouth Colony, in what is now Massachusetts. English colonists and Wampanoag people shared it.
- The Pilgrims crossed the Atlantic Ocean on a ship called the Mayflower in 1620, and the trip took 66 days.
- More than 100 people crowded onto the Mayflower with their belongings, and only one person, a sailor, died during the crossing.
- Their first winter was much harder. Only about half of the passengers survived it.
- In the fall of 1621, after their first harvest came in, the colonists held a celebration that lasted about three days.
- Nobody knows the exact date. Historians at Plimoth Patuxet Museums say it happened sometime between September 21 and November 9, 1621.
- Only one eyewitness description survives: a short letter by a colonist named Edward Winslow.
- Winslow wrote that four men went “fowling,” which means hunting birds. They brought back enough to feed the colony for almost a week.
- The Wampanoag leader Ousamequin, known by his title, the Massasoit, arrived with about 90 men.
- Wampanoag hunters went out and brought back five deer for the feast.
- Nobody at the time called it Thanksgiving. To the English, a thanksgiving was a day of prayer. They held one in the summer of 1623, when rain ended a long drought.
- The name “the First Thanksgiving” caught on in the 1800s, more than 200 years later.
The Wampanoag Side of the Story
The Wampanoag are the Native nation whose homeland includes Plymouth. They were giving thanks for their harvests long before the Mayflower arrived. Thanksgiving does not mean the same thing to every family, and these facts explain why. Wondering how to tell this part of the story without sugarcoating it or making it scary? Start with these facts.
- Wampanoag means “People of the First Light.”
- Wampanoag people say they have lived on this land for more than 15,000 years.
- In the 1600s, as many as 40,000 Wampanoag people lived in 67 villages. Their land stretched across Cape Cod, Martha’s Vineyard, Nantucket and into what is now Rhode Island.
- Long before 1621, Native people held their own thanksgivings, including a Strawberry Thanksgiving and a Green Corn Thanksgiving.
- The colonists built Plymouth on the site of Patuxet, a Wampanoag village.
- Tisquantum, the man the colonists called Squanto, was from Patuxet. In 1614 an English captain tricked him and other Wampanoag men and boys. The captain sold them into slavery in Spain.
- Tisquantum made his way to England and learned English. When he got home in 1619, nearly everyone from his village had died in a terrible epidemic.
- He became an interpreter between the Wampanoag and the colonists. One colonist wrote that Tisquantum caught eels by treading them out of the mud with his bare feet. The eels, he said, were “fat and sweet.”
- Today about 4,000 to 5,000 Wampanoag people live in New England, in communities that include Aquinnah and Mashpee.
- Since 1970, many Native people have gathered in Plymouth on Thanksgiving Day for a National Day of Mourning. A Wampanoag man named Wamsutta Frank James started it. He wanted people to notice how Native people had been written about in history.
What Was Really on the Menu in 1621
The 1621 feast definitely included deer and wild birds, and wild turkey was probably part of it. Pumpkin pie as we know it was not.
- Venison, which is deer meat, was on the table, thanks to the five deer the Wampanoag hunters brought.
- Winslow only wrote “fowl,” a word that could mean ducks, geese or wild turkeys.
- Governor William Bradford wrote that there was a “great store of wild turkeys” around Plymouth that fall, so turkey may well have been served.
- Eels and shellfish such as clams, mussels and lobsters were everyday Wampanoag foods.
- Back then, lobster was ordinary food, while deer and swan were the special treats.
- The Wampanoag grew corn, beans and squash, and they cooked corn into a thick, filling dish called nasaump.
- There was no pumpkin pie as we know it. Sugar and butter had to come from England, and whole years went by without them.
Picture a 7-year-old at the kids’ table who hears that eels were everyday food in 1621. She stares at her plate. Then she asks Grandpa if he would stomp through a muddy river for his dinner. One fact turns “pass the rolls” into ten minutes of talk about how people actually got their food.
Build the 1621 Plate
Tap the foods you think were at the 1621 harvest feast. Each one tells you what historians know.
Your 1621 plate
Your plate is empty. Tap a food to add it.
For fun and learning only. Verdicts come from Plimoth Patuxet Museums and the eyewitness accounts named in the article above. Your picks stay in this browser tab and are not saved or sent anywhere.
How Thanksgiving Became an Official Holiday
Thanksgiving became a yearly national holiday in 1863, when President Abraham Lincoln proclaimed it. Congress locked in the fourth Thursday of November in 1941.
- George Washington named Thursday, November 26, 1789, a national day of thanks, the first under the new Constitution.
- For decades after that, states picked their own Thanksgiving dates.
- A writer and magazine editor named Sarah Josepha Hale began campaigning for a national Thanksgiving in 1846.
- Hale wrote to Presidents Zachary Taylor, Millard Fillmore, Franklin Pierce and James Buchanan, who mostly ignored her.
- She kept at it for 17 years. Hale is also the person who published the nursery rhyme "Mary Had a Little Lamb."
- On October 3, 1863, President Lincoln made Thanksgiving a national holiday, held on the last Thursday of November.
- In 1939, President Franklin Roosevelt moved Thanksgiving one week earlier. Of the states, 32 went along and 16 refused. For two years, the country had two Thanksgivings.
- Congress settled it, and Roosevelt signed the resolution on December 26, 1941: Thanksgiving falls on the fourth Thursday in November.
- Canada has its own Thanksgiving, on the second Monday in October.
Say you lived in 1940, and your cousins lived in a state that refused the change. You could eat turkey at home on one Thursday. Then you could ride to their house for a second Thanksgiving the next week.
Turkey Facts That Will Ruffle Your Feathers
Wild turkeys are fast, chatty birds. According to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, they can run about 18 miles per hour and fly up to 50 miles per hour.
- A male turkey is called a tom or a gobbler, a young male is a jake, and a baby turkey is a poult.
- Turkeys do not just gobble. They also cluck and purr.
- Wild turkeys can run about 18 miles per hour and fly as fast as 50 miles per hour.
- An adult turkey has 5,000 to 6,000 feathers.
- Baby poults gobble up insects first and get more of a taste for plants once they are about four weeks old.
- Toms are not the only show-offs. Some hens strut and fan their tail feathers too.
- The floppy skin that hangs under a turkey's chin is called a wattle.
- Wild turkeys nearly disappeared in the early 1900s. Thanks to conservation work, about 6.5 million wild turkeys now live in the United States, according to the National Wild Turkey Federation.
Got a critter fan at the table? Keep the bird talk going with more animal trivia for kids.
Parades, Pardons and Football
The parade, the turkey pardon and Thanksgiving football are all about 100 years old or younger, far newer than the 1621 harvest.
- The first Macy's parade marched on Thanksgiving Day, November 27, 1924, and it was called the Macy's Christmas Parade.
- Instead of giant balloons, it had animals from the Central Park Zoo.
- Balloons joined the parade in 1927, and the very first one was Felix the Cat.
- The early balloons were let go at the end of the parade. They popped as they floated up. Later balloons carried a return address and a reward for whoever sent them back.
- Presidents spared turkeys now and then, but the official turkey pardon became a yearly tradition in 1989 under President George H.W. Bush.
- The Detroit Lions first played on Thanksgiving in 1934 and have played every Thanksgiving since 1945.
5 Thanksgiving Myths Kids Hear All the Time
Some of the most repeated Thanksgiving "facts" are not true. Here are the big ones, with the real story behind each, and then a Myth or Fact Flip Deck so your Smarty Pants can test what stuck.
- Myth: The Pilgrims ate pumpkin pie. Truth: Without regular sugar and butter from England, there was no pumpkin pie as we know it in 1621.
- Myth: There was definitely no turkey at the first Thanksgiving. Truth: Nobody knows for sure. Winslow wrote "fowl," and Bradford wrote about a "great store of wild turkeys" that fall, so turkey was likely in the mix.
- Myth: Benjamin Franklin wanted the turkey to be the national bird. Truth: In a 1784 letter to his daughter, Franklin called the bald eagle "a Bird of bad moral Character" and the turkey "a much more respectable Bird." But according to the Franklin Institute, he never proposed the turkey as a national symbol.
- Myth: President John F. Kennedy started the turkey pardon. Truth: Kennedy did spare a turkey, but the yearly pardon started in 1989 with President George H.W. Bush.
- Myth: Thanksgiving has been a holiday every year since 1621. Truth: It did not become a yearly national holiday until Lincoln's proclamation in 1863.
Myth or Fact Flip Deck
Read the card out loud. Everyone votes. Then flip it to see who got smarted.
Card 1 of 10
Score: 0 of 0
For fun and learning only. Facts come from the sources named in the article above. Your answers stay in this browser tab and are not saved or sent anywhere.
Which Thanksgiving Facts to Start With
Start with the facts that match your Smarty Pants' age and where you are sharing them. That is 56 facts, which is a lot for one meal. A well-picked five beats a rushed fifty.
If your kids are 5 to 7, start with the turkey facts and the parade. Speeds, feather counts and a zoo parade land fast with little listeners. If your kids are 8 to 11, go for the myths and the two-Thanksgivings story. Older kids love catching grown-ups in a "fact" that turns out to be wrong.
At the dinner table, drop one fact between courses and let it turn into a conversation. In a classroom, the Wampanoag facts and the holiday timeline make a quick lesson anchor, the myth game works as a warm-up, and one of our holiday podcast episodes makes a calm listening break after it.
Say a 4th grade teacher has 10 minutes before lunch on the Wednesday before the break. She reads three myths aloud. The class votes myth or fact with thumbs up or down. Soon the room is arguing about Ben Franklin, and nobody has opened a lunchbox.
The quick win is a dinner with more questions than "pass the potatoes." The bigger one lasts longer: kids who ask "how do we know that?" every time they hear a fact, long after the pie is gone.
Here is a simple plan for this week:
- Pick five facts from two different sections and write them on sticky notes.
- Play the Myth or Fact Flip Deck above on the car ride or at the table.
- Turn the facts into a quiz with these fun Thanksgiving trivia questions, or swap in a few funny Thanksgiving riddles for laughs.
- Keep the history going after the holiday with history trivia for kids. Then try a round of presidents trivia questions, since Washington, Lincoln and Roosevelt all shaped this holiday.
Hear More Thanksgiving Stories on the Who Smarted? Podcast
Who Smarted? is a kids' podcast that turns questions like these into stories, sound effects and big laughs. Our Thanksgiving episodes ask "Did they eat eels at the first Thanksgiving?" and "Why do Americans celebrate Thanksgiving?" They make a great soundtrack for the drive to Grandma's. Listen to Who Smarted? with your family and see who at the table gets smarted first.
