Ask a table of kids whether they would rather eat turkey or pie, and somebody will shout “both” before you finish the question. That is the moment a Thanksgiving would you rather game either takes off or fizzles. This list has 100 kid-safe questions sorted from silly to tricky, a This or That lightning round, and the two rules that keep everyone picking a side.
Twelve of the choices hide a true Thanksgiving fact, each checked against Plimoth Patuxet Museums, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Archives. The questions are written for kids ages 5 to 11 and for the parents, teachers and grandparents doing the asking.
Start with the rules, because they are what turn a list into a game.
The Gobble Picker
Choose your categories, pull a question, and tap a side to count the table’s votes.
Ready? Pull your first question.
Just for fun, not a test. Questions come from the list on this page. Votes stay on this screen and are never saved or sent anywhere.
How to Play Thanksgiving Would You Rather So Nobody Says “Both”
Thanksgiving would you rather has two rules, and they matter more than the questions. Rule one: “both” and “neither” are not answers. You have to pick a side. Rule two: say why in one sentence. The why is where the giggles and the surprisingly smart answers come from.
Picture an 8-year-old at the kids’ table who answers “both!” to the pie question three times in a row. The game stalls, the little cousins copy her, and dinner goes quiet. Add the one-sentence rule and the same kid suddenly argues that apple pie wins because “pumpkin is just a vegetable pretending to be dessert.” That is the game working.
Here is the fastest way to get a table playing:
- Pick one asker. A grown-up for younger kids, the oldest kid for a mixed table.
- Read one question, then count down from three so everyone answers at once.
- Go around the table for the one-sentence why. Anyone can switch sides after hearing the reasons.
- Pass the asking job to whoever gave the funniest reason.
For a big group, point to two sides of the room and have everyone walk to their pick. Kids who are too shy to talk will still happily move, a trick that works just as well with our ice breaker questions.
Funny Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions
Start here when you want the whole table laughing in under a minute. These are pure silliness, so there is no wrong answer, only a funnier reason.
1. Would you rather gobble like a turkey every time you laugh or quack like a duck every time you sneeze?
2. Would you rather wear a pumpkin pie as a hat or wear mashed potato mittens?
3. Would you rather have gravy come out of the bathroom faucet or cranberry sauce come out of the shower?
4. Would you rather have a turkey as your best friend at school or a talking scarecrow as your neighbor?
5. Would you rather sleep in a giant pile of fall leaves or in a giant bowl of stuffing?
6. Would you rather walk like a turkey all day or talk like a turkey all day?
7. Would you rather find a corn kernel in every sock or a cranberry in every shoe?
8. Would you rather ride on top of a giant parade balloon or be one of the people holding its ropes?
9. Would you rather have hair made of autumn leaves or a beard made of whipped cream?
10. Would you rather burp the smell of pumpkin pie or sneeze the smell of roast turkey?
11. Would you rather have a turkey follow you around all day or have a squirrel live in your backpack?
12. Would you rather say “gobble gobble” after every sentence or sing every word you say at dinner?
13. Would you rather eat Thanksgiving dinner with a giant soup ladle or with tiny doll forks?
14. Would you rather wear a turkey costume to school for a day or dress as a pumpkin for a whole week?
15. Would you rather have a pet pie that follows you around or a pet cranberry that bounces everywhere?
16. Would you rather turn orange like a pumpkin when you are happy or red like a cranberry when you are embarrassed?
17. Would you rather have a parade march through your bedroom every morning or a marching band play at every meal?
18. Would you rather slide down a hill of mashed potatoes or swim in a pool of gravy?
Thanksgiving Food Would You Rather Questions
Food questions are where kids dig in hardest, because everyone has a strong opinion about stuffing. Hold the line on rule one here. “I want both” is exactly what grown-ups say about pie, too.
19. Would you rather eat turkey for every meal for a week or never eat turkey again?
20. Would you rather have pumpkin pie or apple pie, if you only get one slice?
21. Would you rather eat only side dishes or only dessert at Thanksgiving dinner?
22. Would you rather give up mashed potatoes or give up stuffing forever?
23. Would you rather eat a whole bowl of cranberry sauce or a whole plate of green beans?
24. Would you rather drink a cup of apple cider or a mug of hot chocolate with dinner?
25. Would you rather eat Thanksgiving dinner for breakfast or pancakes for Thanksgiving dinner?
26. Would you rather get the crispiest piece of turkey skin or the last bite of pie crust?
27. Would you rather eat corn on the cob or a warm buttered roll?
28. Would you rather help bake the pie or help mash the potatoes?
29. Would you rather eat leftovers for three days or try a food you have never eaten before?
30. Would you rather have one pie the size of the table or a hundred tiny pies the size of coins?
31. Would you rather eat dessert first or save your favorite bite for last?
32. Would you rather have marshmallows on everything or gravy on everything?
33. Would you rather eat a leftover turkey sandwich or a leftover turkey pizza the next day?
34. Would you rather choose the whole dinner menu or choose only the desserts?
35. Would you rather have whipped cream that never runs out or dinner rolls that never run out?
36. Would you rather eat your favorite Thanksgiving food twice or taste three foods you have never tried?
Turkey and Animal Would You Rather Questions
Animal questions work for the youngest players, because a 5-year-old can picture a turkey even if she cannot picture “hosting.” Save these for when attention starts to drift.
37. Would you rather be a turkey that can fly or a turkey that can swim?
38. Would you rather have a turkey’s fan of tail feathers or a peacock’s?
39. Would you rather be a squirrel gathering nuts for winter or a bear sleeping through it?
40. Would you rather be able to talk to turkeys or talk to deer?
41. Would you rather take care of a baby turkey or a baby goat?
42. Would you rather be a wild turkey in the woods or a duck on a pond?
43. Would you rather have a turkey’s wobbly wattle or an elephant’s long trunk?
44. Would you rather visit a turkey farm or a pumpkin patch?
45. Would you rather be a goose flying south for the winter or a chipmunk hiding food underground?
46. Would you rather be chased by a turkey or chased by a goose?
47. Would you rather have a cow that gives chocolate milk or a hen that lays golden eggs?
48. Would you rather be as fast as a running turkey or as quiet as a flying owl?
Would You Rather Questions With a Smarty Fact Behind Them
Every question in this set has a true fact hiding behind one of the choices. Ask the question, let everyone pick and give their reason, then read the Smarty Fact out loud. Kids remember a fact far better when they have just argued about it.
Say your 7-year-old picks the one-hour dinner over the three-day party because “three days is too much pie.” Then you read that the people at the 1621 harvest celebration really did feast for three days. That surprised face is what this section is for.
The Smarty Fact Flip
Pick a side on each card to flip it and reveal the true Thanksgiving fact hiding behind it.
Facts checked against Plimoth Patuxet Museums, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Archives. For learning and fun, not a test. Your picks stay on this screen and are never saved or sent anywhere.
49. Would you rather go to a Thanksgiving dinner that lasts one hour or a celebration that lasts three whole days?
Smarty Fact: The 1621 harvest celebration that later became known as the first Thanksgiving lasted three days. Pilgrim Edward Winslow described it in a letter, the only firsthand account that survives, according to Plimoth Patuxet Museums.
50. Would you rather invite 90 guests to dinner or cook for just your own family?
Smarty Fact: Massasoit, a leader of the Wampanoag people, came to the 1621 celebration with about 90 of his men. Winslow wrote that the English "entertained and feasted" them for three days.
51. Would you rather bring deer meat or a basket of fish to share at a feast?
Smarty Fact: Winslow wrote that the Wampanoag men went out and killed five deer, which they brought to the colony and gave to the governor and other leaders.
52. Would you rather go hunting for birds with three friends or stay home and set the table?
Smarty Fact: Before the feast, the governor sent four men out "fowling." Winslow wrote that in one day they brought back enough birds to feed the colony for almost a week.
53. Would you rather celebrate Thanksgiving in late September or in November?
Smarty Fact: Nobody knows the exact date of the 1621 celebration. Plimoth Patuxet Museums says it happened sometime between September 21 and November 9, 1621.
54. Would you rather eat lobster or eel?
Smarty Fact: In the 1600s, lobster around Plymouth was everyday food, while deer and swan were treats. The Wampanoag fished ponds and rivers for herring, trout, catfish and eels. Who Smarted? has a whole episode asking, "Did they eat eels at the first Thanksgiving?"
55. Would you rather go a whole year without sugar or a whole year without butter?
Smarty Fact: The Plymouth colonists sometimes went whole years without imported goods like sugar and butter, according to Plimoth Patuxet Museums. That makes a 1621 pumpkin pie very unlikely.
56. Would you rather run as fast as a wild turkey or fly as fast as a wild turkey?
Smarty Fact: Fly, if you want speed. Wild turkeys can run about 18 miles per hour and fly up to 50 miles per hour, according to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
57. Would you rather count every feather on a turkey or every kernel on an ear of corn?
Smarty Fact: Bring a snack. An adult turkey has 5,000 to 6,000 feathers, says the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
58. Would you rather eat what a baby turkey eats or what a grown-up turkey eats?
Smarty Fact: Baby turkeys are called poults, and they gobble up insects. They start eating more plants after they are about four weeks old.
59. Would you rather gobble or purr?
Smarty Fact: Trick question: turkeys do both. Besides gobbling, turkeys also cluck and purr. A male turkey is called a tom or a gobbler.
60. Would you rather have Thanksgiving on the last Thursday of November or the fourth Thursday?
Smarty Fact: In 1939, President Franklin D. Roosevelt moved Thanksgiving a week earlier, and some states refused to go along. In 1941, Congress made the fourth Thursday of November the official date, according to the National Archives.
Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions That Make You Think
These are the slower questions, the ones that get a kid talking about who they are thankful for without anyone asking "so, what are you thankful for?" in that voice. Use them after the food arrives, when the table settles.
Say your table has a quiet 10-year-old cousin who has not said a word since the car ride. Number 66 hands him something he knows more about than anyone: what he would teach his grandmother. Questions like that open up kids who freeze when asked to talk about feelings.
61. Would you rather write a thank-you note to a teacher or to a friend?
62. Would you rather help cook the whole meal or help clean up after it?
63. Would you rather share your dessert with someone who did not get any or give your seat to someone who is tired?
64. Would you rather say what you are thankful for out loud or write it on a card for someone to read?
65. Would you rather spend Thanksgiving with a huge crowd of relatives or a small group of your favorite people?
66. Would you rather learn a family recipe from a grandparent or teach a grandparent your favorite game?
67. Would you rather help at a food drive or make cards for your neighbors?
68. Would you rather see how your family celebrated Thanksgiving 50 years ago or how it will look 50 years from now?
69. Would you rather have a day to thank everyone you know or a day where everyone thanks you?
70. Would you rather start a brand-new family tradition or keep every old one exactly the same?
71. Would you rather be thankful for something big, like your home, or something small, like warm socks, for a whole day?
72. Would you rather eat at a long fancy table or have a Thanksgiving picnic on the living room floor?
73. Would you rather help a younger cousin at the kids' table or sit quietly with the grown-ups and just listen?
74. Would you rather give a toast at dinner or make a name card for every seat?
Easy Thanksgiving Would You Rather for Younger Kids
Ages 4 to 7 need choices they can see in their heads, two things, both real, no "what if" chains. Keep the asking quick and cheer every answer. If you are hosting a kids' table with toddlers on the end, start here and move up.
75. Would you rather be a turkey or a pumpkin?
76. Would you rather eat a red cranberry or an orange carrot?
77. Would you rather jump in a pile of leaves or roll down a grassy hill?
78. Would you rather draw a hand turkey or color a big pumpkin?
79. Would you rather have pie or ice cream?
80. Would you rather wear a big scarf or fuzzy mittens?
81. Would you rather see a parade balloon shaped like a dog or like a dinosaur?
82. Would you rather eat with a spoon or with a fork?
83. Would you rather take a nap after dinner or play outside after dinner?
84. Would you rather be a leaf falling from a tree or an acorn on the ground?
85. Would you rather gobble like a turkey or moo like a cow?
86. Would you rather pick apples or pick pumpkins?
87. Would you rather wear a crown made of leaves or a hat shaped like a turkey?
Hard Thanksgiving Would You Rather for Older Kids
Ages 8 to 11 like a question with a real trade-off, where both sides cost something. These make great car-ride debates on the way to dinner.
88. Would you rather plan the entire Thanksgiving menu or wash every dish by yourself?
89. Would you rather host Thanksgiving for 20 people or travel 10 hours to get to dinner?
90. Would you rather know everyone's favorite food at the table or everyone's favorite memory?
91. Would you rather cook the turkey with no recipe or bake a pie with half the recipe missing?
92. Would you rather give up Thanksgiving leftovers or give up Thanksgiving dessert?
93. Would you rather ride on a parade float or be the announcer describing the parade on TV?
94. Would you rather travel back to 1621 for one day or forward to Thanksgiving in the year 2100?
95. Would you rather explain the history of Thanksgiving to the whole table or answer everyone's trivia questions?
96. Would you rather be in charge of where everyone sits or in charge of serving everyone?
97. Would you rather eat a meal made only from food grown near your house or only from food grown on the other side of the world?
98. Would you rather have Thanksgiving with no electricity or with no oven?
99. Would you rather invent a new Thanksgiving food or a new Thanksgiving game?
100. Would you rather be thanked by a stranger for a kindness or never be thanked but know you helped?
Thanksgiving This or That Lightning Round
This or That is would you rather on fast-forward: two words, no explaining, answer in one second. Read these as quickly as you can and see who hesitates. If your crew loves this format, there are 150 more in our this or that game for kids.
- Turkey or ham?
- Pumpkin pie or apple pie?
- Mashed potatoes or stuffing?
- Gravy or cranberry sauce?
- Parade or football?
- Dinner rolls or cornbread?
- Fall leaves or first snow?
- Apple cider or hot chocolate?
- Kids' table or grown-up table?
- Nap or walk after dinner?
- Pie or cake?
- Drumstick or wing?
- Sweet potatoes or green beans?
- Hosting or visiting?
- Cooking or cleaning up?
- Scarf or hat?
- Apple picking or pumpkin picking?
- Board game or movie?
- Leftover sandwich or leftover pie?
- Thank-you card or thank-you hug?
Thanksgiving Would You Rather for Kids and Classrooms: Pick the Way You Play
Thanksgiving would you rather works anywhere kids gather, from the kids' table to a classroom the day before break. Before you start, think about how much time you have and how many kids are playing, because that decides which version to run.
For Kids at the Kids' Table
Who Smarted? asked "Did they eat eels at the first Thanksgiving?" in an episode released November 22, 2023, and that question makes a perfect opener for the drive to dinner. Play it in the car from our Thanksgiving episodes, then start the table with question 54, lobster or eel, and watch the kids who listened explain the answer to the ones who did not. At a table with a wide age range, let the oldest kid read the questions and start with the easy set for younger kids. A kid who gets to be the asker stops racing to finish dinner.
For the Classroom
The "Trusty Trivia: THANKSGIVING!!!" episode from November 27, 2025 runs 4 minutes and 25 seconds, short enough to fit a brain break before recess. Play it, then run five would you rather questions with kids walking to one side of the room or the other instead of answering out loud. That keeps 25 kids moving and quiet ones included, and it ends in about 10 minutes. For a longer block, follow up with fun Thanksgiving trivia and let teams score points.
Thanksgiving Would You Rather FAQ
What are good Thanksgiving would you rather questions for kids?
Good ones give two real, kid-sized choices and nothing heavy. Food choices like pumpkin pie or apple pie, silly choices like gobbling when you laugh, and fact choices like running or flying as fast as a wild turkey all work. Skip anything about grown-up arguments or scary topics.
Are there November would you rather questions?
Yes. Any question in the funny, food or turkey sections works all November, and the fall picks in the younger-kid list (leaves, scarves, apple picking) work from Halloween to the first snow.
What if my kid always says "both"?
Make "both" a lost turn. Then ask for one sentence of why. Kids who say "both" are usually avoiding the explaining part, not the choosing part, and the one-sentence rule makes the explaining feel small enough to try.
Want more ways to keep the table busy? Try our funny Thanksgiving riddles, the full set of would you rather questions for kids for the rest of the year, or family trivia questions that grandparents can win too.
Keep the Questions Coming With Who Smarted?
The best Thanksgiving question is the one a kid is still arguing about in the car home. That curiosity is what every episode of Who Smarted? is built on, with short, funny shows that answer the questions kids actually ask, from eels at the first Thanksgiving to why Americans celebrate Thanksgiving at all. Find a new episode to share any night of the year on the Who Smarted? kids' podcast.
